Delivery slots are filling up quickly Check Available Slots
Shopping Basket

Sticky Toffee Cake

See customer reviews

A sticky toffee pudding cake with a home-made date puree filled sticky sponge & and toffee butter cream.

Ingredients & Allergens

Dates- close up
Toffee melted- close up

What's in the mix?

Home-made date puree, free range eggs, golden syrup and treacle create our deliciously sticky toffee pudding sponge. The buttercream is made with natural toffee and vanilla flavouring and British butter.

Toffee sponge cake filling butter icing close up

Sumptuous Buttercream

Natural toffee and natural vanilla flavouring are whipped together with British butter to create a thick and comforting toffee buttercream.

Sticky Toffee sponge cut out

How do I look?

Our Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake is a twist on the Great British Classic. Our home-made date puree with treacle and syrup creates the most comfortingly sticky Sponge which is held together with a warming toffee butter cream.

STORAGE - Please store me in an air-tight container in a cosy spot - I don't like being kept in the fridge. Can be frozen for up to 6 months.

How do I arrive?

Our sponge cakes are packaged in secure and robust packaging. The inner box is wrapped around the cake to securely hold it in place so the sides and top do not get damaged in transit. The box also includes a handy cutting guide! It is then put in a strong cardboard outer box for extra protection so it will arrive to you safely.

Line drawing of a cake
Product Serves Pack Weight Cake Diameter Cake Depth Ambient Shelf Life
Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge 0.1kg 0.00cm 0.00cm 7 days
Sticky Toffee Wedge 0kg 0.00cm 0.00cm 7 days
Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8 8 1kg 17.00cm 8.00cm 7 days
Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16 16 2kg 24.00cm 8.00cm 7 days


  • Amanda N - 21/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Sticky toffee was so good. Bought it for my nephew's birthday and he said it's the best cake he's ever had.
  • Lauretta B - 20/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Absolutely delicious! Everybody really enjoyed it. The flavour was perfect and t was very moist.
  • philippa W - 18/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    This sponge had a great flavour, was very moist and was loved by all ages!!
  • MARY S - 18/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    I ordered the Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake for a family reunion/birthday celebration. The cake impressed everybody, we all have varying preferences, so it was difficult to decide which cake to choose. It was soft, moist and both the cake and the buttercream were beautifully flavoured. The delivery options were spot on, I opted for delivery before 12.30pm. The cake appeared to be vacuum packed, which meant it was kept impeccably fresh until it was cut and served. I will definitely reorder, hoping to try the Apple Crumble Cake next time.
  • sara h - 15/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    So moist and soft but still easy to cut. A real hit with lots of people coming back for seconds!
  • Sandra B - 15/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Everyone loved the sticky toffee pudding cake, moist and flavoursome and moerish!
  • Gloria G - 15/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    My daughter, son-in-law and two grandsons enjoy your cakes. We live a fair distance away from each other so if I can't get to see them all with a homemade cake I find it very easy to order one of yours - and they're always very grateful. Is it because they don't like mine I wonder!!!
  • Lorna M - 09/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Delicious! Amazing flavours and lasts well once cut.
  • Linda S - 08/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Amazing cake - excellent quality, fresh, smooth with just enough sticky toffee flavouring though a little more strength of this flavour would have been welcome. But absolutely no complaints. First class.
  • Lisa B - 06/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Awesome, had a really moist & soft texture. Everyone loved it. We will most definitely be ordering again at some point. Perfect sapphire wedding cake for the inlaws.
  • Lynne W - 03/09/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    The Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake Was Also A Great Favourite and Again So Moist and Tasty - We All Loved The Cake.
  • Lynn N - 17/08/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Another lovely Sticky Toffee Pudding cake from Sponge. We’ve had so many good ones that we daren’t try another flavour, because how could it be better?
  • Mary N - 17/08/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    Buttercream was rich and tasted like toffee caramel, and the sponge was perfect…not dry, not wet, not overly fluffy, nor dense. Perfect.
  • Wendy B - 16/08/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Amazing moist delicious huge cake Birthday cake and said best cake ever!
  • Vicky S - 11/08/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Tasty cake, not too sickly sweet or heavy. I would have preferred a more interesting topping as it did look a bit plain, maybe a drizzle or some chunks of toffee? Delicious though!
  • STEPHEN H - 03/08/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Really lovely sponge. Cream filling a little too sweet.
  • Sarah p - 23/07/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Friend said was excellent when she received it through the post. Looked and tasted exceptional.
  • Michael C - 21/07/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    As I noted above there was a major delivery error which basically ruined everything about my order. At first customer service said they would have the cake collected and redelivered but the party the cake was intended for was over at that point, and who wants a cake that’s been at a stranger’s house?! I was not happy. But, Amy, the offered a full refund. This should probably have been the first option, but I was grateful for it. It didn’t take the sting out of the delivery disaster and the fact that my dad didn’t get his birthday cake (I live in the US and couldn’t be there which just made it worse), but it was the right thing to do. I would note that I don’t hold Sponge responsible as such, it was DHL that stupidly messed things up. I would also note that, ironically, someone brought a cake they had ordered from Sponge to my dad’s party. Everyone loves Sponge apparently!
  • A E Keith Y - 20/07/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Cake really well received and thoroughly enjoyed by all. Moist and a great taste
  • Diane C - 18/07/2021
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Sent for my sister's birthday. She said it was delicious. Thanks

Have you tried?

Sticky Toffee Cake

Sugar, water, self raising flour (wheat flour, raising agents (sodium bicarbonate, mono calcium phosphate), calcium carbonate, iron, niacin, thiamin), margarine (palm oil, rapeseed oil, salt, emulsifier E475, flavouring, sunflower oil, colours (curcumin, annatto), dates, eggs, butter (milk), golden syrup, treacle, raising agent (sodium bicarbonate), natural vanilla flavour, natural toffee flavour.

ALLERGENS IN BOLD. Made in a bakery which handles gluten, eggs, nuts, milk, soya & sulphites.

All of our cakes are baked in the same kitchen and although we do all we can to minimise the risk of cross-contamination we cannot 100% guarantee this.

  • Has Gluten containing cereals
    Contains Gluten
  • Contains Milk
    Contains Milk
  • Contains Eggs
    Contains Eggs
  • Suitable for Vegetarians
    Suitable for Vegetarians

Did you know?

Our special twist on the Great British Classic of Sticky Toffee pudding, is great for all occasions! Sticky Toffee Pudding Sponge is perfect for cuddling up with by the fire. It is also delicious warmed up with cream or custard poured all over it for the ultimate treat! Great for helping you to warm up in the colder months, although can be enjoyed at anytime throughout the year.

Personalise your order by adding cake toppers, balloons, candles, greeting cards, drinks and more. To create the perfect celebration cake, ready for any occasion! We have a great selection of cake toppers that can go on your Sticky Toffee Sponge. Including Happy Birthday ones, Christening, Anniversary, and children's ones! Designs include unicorns, princesses, dinosaurs, diggers, fairies and mermaids. There is something for everyone!

Let us know how you eat yours and send in your Sponge Moment! We give a Super Sharing Sponge away each month to the best Sponge Moment! Take a photo of you eating, receiving or posing with your Sponge Cake and send it to us! The more creative you are the more chance you have of winning :)Send by email, Twitter,Facebook or Instagram

STORAGE - Please store me in an air-tight container in a cosy spot - I don't like being kept in the fridge. Can be frozen for up to 6 months.