LOCKDOWN UPDATE - we're still baking! more info
Shopping Basket

Sticky Toffee Cake

See customer reviews

A sticky toffee pudding cake with a home-made date puree filled sticky sponge & and toffee butter cream.

Ingredients & Allergens

Dates- close up
Toffee melted- close up

What's in the mix?

Home-made date puree, free range eggs, golden syrup and treacle create our deliciously sticky toffee pudding sponge. The buttercream is made with natural toffee and vanilla flavouring and British butter.

Toffee sponge cake filling butter icing close up

Sumptuous Buttercream

Natural toffee and natural vanilla flavouring are whipped together with British butter to create a thick and comforting toffee buttercream.

Sticky Toffee sponge cut out

How do I look?

Our Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake is a twist on the Great British Classic. Our home-made date puree with treacle and syrup creates the most comfortingly sticky Sponge which is held together with a warming toffee butter cream.

STORAGE - Please store me in an air-tight container in a cosy spot - I don't like being kept in the fridge. Can be frozen for up to 6 months.

How do I arrive?

Our sponge cakes are packaged in secure and robust packaging. The inner box is wrapped around the cake to securely hold it in place so the sides and top do not get damaged in transit. The box also includes a handy cutting guide! It is then put in a strong cardboard outer box for extra protection so it will arrive to you safely.

Line drawing of a cake
Product Serves Pack Weight Cake Diameter Cake Depth Ambient Shelf Life
Sticky Toffee Baby Sponge 0.1kg 0.00cm 0.00cm 7 days
Sticky Toffee Wedge 0kg 0.00cm 0.00cm 7 days
Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8 8 1kg 17.00cm 8.00cm 7 days
Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16 16 2kg 24.00cm 8.00cm 7 days


  • Sheila A - 21/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    Sublime! Beautiful rich moist cake. The buttercream is to die for. We love it so much my husband ordered s 16 portion stick toffee for my birthday just for us!!! Why bother baking your own & certainly don't buy a supermarket cake!! Delicious. ❤️
  • Nisha W - 18/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    I have now ordered birthday cakes twice during lockdown for my in-laws (two different flavours) and they have loved the cakes. They were delivered on time, inexpensive, but (according to them) delicious. I appreciated the easy ordering, responsive customer service, email updates on the status of the order, on-time delivery, and variety of cake options available. I will be using Sponge many times in the future.
  • Mary O - 15/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    delicious will be ordering again and no just for a birthday but for a little treat
  • LINDA M - 11/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Great fresh good ingredients . Well packaged. Everyone enjoyed the cake very true to flavour.
  • Julie L - 11/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Making the ordering really easy and letting me know what stage the order was at kept me informed. There were no horrible surprises, everything worked really well and I would definitely use you again.
  • Nancy A - 10/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Lovely moist sponge cake, a bit pricey but great for a special occasion.
  • Julia R - 09/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Wish I could have tasted it; lucky recipients! I hope someone sends me one of your cakes so I can fill in this box. They look delicious though.
  • Dawn G - 09/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    Very tasty cake, arrived on time and stayed moist for 7 days.
  • Kate L - 01/11/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    Wonderful flavour, moist cake. Addictive, and will certainly be ordering again.
  • zoe c - 25/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    I ordered this for friends who have family in hospital - they said it was a lovely treat & they really enjoyed it - much better than anything they might get at the shop!
  • Lynn N - 22/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Yet another sticky toffee Sponge cake for my son went down a treat with his new university flatmates. They are still raving about it!
  • Shaun T - 20/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    This was one of the best, could really get the sticky toffee flavour.
  • Joanne G - 20/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    My daughter chose this cake for her 6th birthday and we chose some sparkler candles to go with it which were brilliant! We all really enjoyed the cake and icing, it was very tasty and not dry at all. My daughter doesn’t usually finish a slice of cake but went back for seconds of this so it was a good success! Thank you
  • ruth s - 18/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    I have had a few sticky toffee pudding sponges and this one certainly was. It was way too moist and got stuck to the roof of my mouth. It certainly wasn't like the others I have had. I don't know if it needed a little longer in the oven or too much glue added. LOL
  • Rich M - 18/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Thank you for our daughters lovely cake it made her day!
  • Stephen B - 17/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Lovely cake and tasted so good. We have used this company several times before.
  • steven k - 14/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    Normally moist but was very dry. I've had it previously and it was really good. Not very impressed this time
  • Jane L - 12/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    It was fantastic!! It as the second I have bought - the first ended up being frozen for three months before eating and it was still delicious!
  • Sandra S - 05/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 16
    already covered in full review. Fabulous product, moisture, tasty and yummy
  • steven k - 05/10/2020
    Sticky Toffee Pudding for 8
    Never tasted anything so good. I would order again. Wouldn't mind something with cherries in

Have you tried?

Sticky Toffee Cake

Sugar, water, self raising flour (wheat flour, raising agents (sodium bicarbonate, mono calcium phosphate), calcium carbonate, iron, niacin, thiamin), margarine (palm oil, rapeseed oil, salt, emulsifier E475, flavouring, sunflower oil, colours (curcumin, annatto), dates, eggs, butter (milk), golden syrup, treacle, raising agent (sodium bicarbonate), natural vanilla flavour, natural toffee flavour.

ALLERGENS IN BOLD. Made in a bakery which handles gluten, eggs, nuts, milk, soya & sulphites.

All of our cakes are baked in the same kitchen and although we do all we can to minimise the risk of cross-contamination we cannot 100% guarantee this.

  • Has Gluten containing cereals
    Contains Gluten
  • Contains Milk
    Contains Milk
  • Contains Eggs
    Contains Eggs
  • Suitable for Vegetarians
    Suitable for Vegetarians

Did you know?

Our special twist on the Great British Classic of Sticky Toffee pudding, is great for all occasions! Sticky Toffee Pudding Sponge is perfect for cuddling up with by the fire. It is also delicious warmed up with cream or custard poured all over it for the ultimate treat! Great for helping you to warm up in the colder months, although can be enjoyed at anytime throughout the year.

Personalise your order by adding cake toppers, balloons, candles, greeting cards, drinks and more. To create the perfect celebration cake, ready for any occasion! We have a great selection of cake toppers that can go on your Sticky Toffee Sponge. Including Happy Birthday ones, Christening, Anniversary, and children's ones! Designs include unicorns, princesses, dinosaurs, diggers, fairies and mermaids. There is something for everyone!

Let us know how you eat yours and send in your Sponge Moment! We give a Super Sharing Sponge away each month to the best Sponge Moment! Take a photo of you eating, receiving or posing with your Sponge Cake and send it to us! The more creative you are the more chance you have of winning :)Send by email, Twitter,Facebook or Instagram

STORAGE - Please store me in an air-tight container in a cosy spot - I don't like being kept in the fridge. Can be frozen for up to 6 months.